Wed May 18, 2011 9:07 pm
1862 PLAN REVIEW
Optimize Army of the Potomac with two maneuver Corps. Optimize Army of the James. Optimize Army of the Ohio with two maneuver Corps. Build Western Army. Mission Accomplished. The AOTP has two maneuver Corps (Hooker and Meade) with McDowell Corps for support, plus Halleck Corps at WDC.
Secure Potomac River Line: garrison Leonardtown MD and Port Tobacco MD; take Winchester VA; raise loyalty along B&O railway. Advance and develop Rappahannock River Line: take and garrison Fredericksburg VA. Prepare for advance to the James River line. Mission Accomplished. The bar was set pretty low –the CSA did get a raider into Pennsylvania to disrupt rail – but no real threats.
Ohio River line: take and garrison Louisville KY and build depot and fort. Build depot and garrison Ironton OH. Take and garrison Clarksburg KY and Lexington KY. Prepare for advance to the Cumberland River line. Mission Failed. Louisville is defended by a strong CSA Army with two Corps. The CSA fort at Paducah disrupted Union naval operations. The Union is building forts at Evansville and Cincinnati to disrupt the CSA naval operations. Union land forces are less than equal to CSA forces. The Union liberated Lexington KY and Clarksburg KY. Mission Failed even worse than when I wrote this…. The CSA took Cincinnati before the fort was complete.
Mississippi River Line: build fort and garrison at Cairo IL; build fort and garrison at St Louis MO. Advance and develop Missouri River line: take and garrison and build depot at Bloomington MO; raise loyalty along MO railway. Mission Accomplished. Forts are operational and strongly garrisoned at Cairo and St Louis. Require depot and garrison at Bloomington MO.
Take and garrison and build fort at Richmond VA. Mission Failed. Union forces are advancing - McClellan and Butler believe that Richmond will fall by the end of Summer.
Execute Operation Whisky XX. Mission Failed. The forces allocated to this Operation are fortunate to be alive.
Conduct coastal raid, VA raid, and KY raid. Unsatisfactory. The Operation Whisky XX coastal raid didn’t destroy the Wilmington Depot (but now I know that commanders must be activated to destroy a depot) and even worse, the CSA division that responded to the raid ended up reinforcing the CSA defense of Virginia.
Plan and execute secret Operation if conditions permit (I have an idea for one). Overcome by events.
The Naval plan is to maintain the Atlantic Blockade; maintain force at Ohio and Mississippi River confluent; maintain force at Hampton Roads; blockade Richmond VA; develop transport capability. Unsatisfactory. The Atlantic Blockade is operational; the Gulf Blockade is nearly operational. Rotating fleets will ensure that a fleet is always on station. The loss of an ironclad fleet to CSA Fort Paducah changed the operating environment for Union river fleets – until land forces clear the forts, river fleets are docked. Dahlgren maintains a strong monitor / blockade fleet at Hampton Roads, with occasional port calls for rest and refit. Richmond is not under blockade. The Union has enough transport capability for coastal operations. The loss of the river fleet accounts for the unsatisfactory assessment – the bluewater navy is satisfactory.
Quartermaster Plan: build depots at Jersey City, Buffalo, Boston, and Fort Laramie. Maintain rail / river / ocean supply at average to full. Ensure that key garrisons have Supply Wagons to minimize risk of capture. Mission Accomplished. Depots are garrisoned. Require Jersey City and Buffalo depots. Rail and River supply are usually at excess but never below average. Ocean supply is available except when fleet is in port. Supply wagons are at key garrisons.
The Economic plan is to industrialize front-line states for General Supply and Ammunition. Mission accomplished. The Union has more GS, Ammo, and WS than it can use.
Overall, the Union is making slow progress in the East, small progress in Kentucky, and stable in the West. McClellan and Butler are hammering at CSA forces in Virginia and have better locations to rest and replace than the CSA. Additional divisions are being deployed to the theater. The Ohio line is being heavily fortified and the CSA will have increasing difficulty keeping Louisville supplied. The forts may also inhibit raiders from disrupting rail. Union forces are being reinforced to resume the offensive. The West is stable except for raiders.
The Bluewater Navy is ahead of schedule for deploying blockade squadrons.