Not much of an AAR. Just to post that as the CSA, I got a Stalemate. Victory points for CSA was 124 and for USA, 35. National Morale was CSA 112 and USA 92. CSA had control of Memphis the whole time, and Nashville for about half the game.
Lotta fun.
Seems to be realistic, however, I couldn't get Cheathem to form a division. His divisional HQ was there, as was he. I could never get them to combine.