So I started my first GC as USA, and I'm at Jan 1860 now, on eve of Civil War. My economy is pretty good, and I have built up a sizable military in preparation for upcoming war. But I still have some questions.
1. Since around 2-3 years ago (right after Buchanan took over as president), I cannot use "state visit" in diplomacy anymore. Is this normal for US before civil war or is it a bug? I see AI nations still using state visits and I have had a state visit request from Mexico, but I cannot initiate one anymore.
2. I built a tea plantation in Nepal and Gems mine in Burma way back (both inland), but I cannot collect their products. Do I have to build railroad to nearest port for me to connect the resources?
3. So far I don't have many generals. Will historical generals pop up once Civil War start (Grant, Sherman, etc)?
1. Your abilities on the diplomatic front directly tie to your leaderships ability scores (diplomacy, imperialism, and administration). You may have an inactive congress (the US has some of the worst luck when it comes to that), and thus lose some diplomatic options that you had before. I say inactive, as there is a congress that has a -3 in administration (I think), and 0 for the other two scores.
2. You need a collection point nearby (or the country that owns it needs one). You also need a fleet in the appropriate MTB. To see your collection points, click the lower left button near the world map.
3. You should get more generals over time (an expanding pool). I have not made it to the civil war yet, so don't know how many.
FYI - if you have a large army, you may not be able to produce any replacements, as the army expands greatly by event at the start of the war.
2. You need a collection point nearby (or the country that owns it needs one). You also need a fleet in the appropriate MTB. To see your collection points, click the lower left button near the world map.
3. You should get more generals over time (an expanding pool). I have not made it to the civil war yet, so don't know how many.
FYI - if you have a large army, you may not be able to produce any replacements, as the army expands greatly by event at the start of the war.
Remember - The beatings will continue until morale improves.
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
-
Jonathan Pollard
- Major
- Posts: 220
- Joined: Mon May 26, 2008 4:01 am
- Location: Federal Prison
- Contact: Website
Jim-NC wrote:2. You need a collection point nearby (or the country that owns it needs one). You also need a fleet in the appropriate MTB. To see your collection points, click the lower left button near the world map.
If your structure is very far inland you won't be able to do anything to get its production, because some inland locations do not connect to any MTBs.
"Two suspects are in FBI custody after a truckload of explosives was discovered around the George Washington Bridge...the FBI...says enough explosives were in the truck to do great damage to the George Washington Bridge." Dan Rather of CBS News, 9/11/2001
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
2 turns after posting this thread, Civil War started. I was very unpleasantly surprised by what happened! first, I had saved 280/335 recruits to use to build a inf corp immediately after start of war, but war event reduced my recruits to 0/0. What a waste of 300+ recruits! And, my National moral dropped to 0! It will take many months to build back up. This is such a bad situation, since the fastest way to gain NM is to win battles, but with your NM so low, your troops will not fight very well so it's hard to win battles. Well, at least the F10 screen shows CSA having only power rating of 38. I hope things will get better once Lincoln comes to power, but that won't happened for another year. It will be funny if I manage to win the war before Lincoln comes to power.
thanks for the responses, btw!
thanks for the responses, btw!
From my games as the US, those missing conscripts usually seemed to be turned into replacement chits. Its something that you get to anticipate after a few games, though yes, it is very frustrating! Also, which version are you playing? the dropping to 0NM didn't happen to me with 1.04rc2 (though I did have other problems which have put that game on hold).
Unfortunately, some known issues.
1) The script of the Civil War adds too many officers and conscripts which somehow throws an error and the engine substracts or nullifies instead of adding the supposed extra soldiers.
2) The Generals/Admirals script is nonexistent. In all my games I have submitted updated decennial or special event quotas. As soon as I finish with the Großdeutschland Mod I will get into authoring these quotas once and for all, for all gamers. In the meantime see here. USA should have got extra Generals/Admirals already by 1860. And not only USA, many nations... there are some numbers in the databases given by the developers.
3) My proposed fix will also use MacNaughton's quotas (possibly further balanced and adapted) so to give other minor nations quotas as well. Otherwise when the initial leaders die no other come into play: by default the quotas are set to 0!!
4) That said, do NOT despair. The fact of the matter is this: as a human player you have hindsight of the events and approximate time of the start of hostilities in the Civil War. This means that you can prepare for it, while the event spawning the CSA forces is not dynamic (in theory events with evaluation conditions could have been set to spawn rival armed forces according to the number of forces the player uses). So the fact that your soldiers went to 0, might be a boon from a challenge point of view.
5) Do not worry about your NM. After the initial shock it shall go up fairly quickly. If you feel uncompetitive, simply avoid battles for a couple of months (4-5 turns) as it rises.
1) The script of the Civil War adds too many officers and conscripts which somehow throws an error and the engine substracts or nullifies instead of adding the supposed extra soldiers.
2) The Generals/Admirals script is nonexistent. In all my games I have submitted updated decennial or special event quotas. As soon as I finish with the Großdeutschland Mod I will get into authoring these quotas once and for all, for all gamers. In the meantime see here. USA should have got extra Generals/Admirals already by 1860. And not only USA, many nations... there are some numbers in the databases given by the developers.
3) My proposed fix will also use MacNaughton's quotas (possibly further balanced and adapted) so to give other minor nations quotas as well. Otherwise when the initial leaders die no other come into play: by default the quotas are set to 0!!
4) That said, do NOT despair. The fact of the matter is this: as a human player you have hindsight of the events and approximate time of the start of hostilities in the Civil War. This means that you can prepare for it, while the event spawning the CSA forces is not dynamic (in theory events with evaluation conditions could have been set to spawn rival armed forces according to the number of forces the player uses). So the fact that your soldiers went to 0, might be a boon from a challenge point of view.
5) Do not worry about your NM. After the initial shock it shall go up fairly quickly. If you feel uncompetitive, simply avoid battles for a couple of months (4-5 turns) as it rises.
Care to unify Germany as Austria? Recreate the Holy Roman Empire of the 20th Century:
Großdeutschland Mod
Are you tough enough to impersonate the Shogun and defy the Westerners? Prove it:
Shogun Defiance Mod (completed AAR)
Großdeutschland Mod
Are you tough enough to impersonate the Shogun and defy the Westerners? Prove it:
Shogun Defiance Mod (completed AAR)
re: Kensai: Thanks for the response, I tried to open your link, but it won't let me view it, even after I register for the paradox forum.
It's been 1 year since war started, and I still don't have any new generals. I did discover a bug though. So before the war, I colonized Oklahoma and Arizona so the cherokee and apachee Indians are under my command, with general Stand Watie. I put them all in Oklahoma before the war. When War started, a found the CSA has a new general Stand Watie, but I still have same general under me too. So now there are 2 generals Stand Watie on the map! I didn't know 19th century cloning technology was so advanced!
Anyway, in the first year of war I was not impressed with AI tactical abilities. It sent the Army of Northern VA to the west, trying to take Southern Illonois, but failed and was cut off. Now it is trapped and rotting in Ohio. Meanwhile, in the absence of his big army, I was able to march down VA and surround Richmond. So 1 year into the war, the CSA capital is besieged, and its best army is doomed to be destroyed in Ohio, and I also took most of Texas after he vacated his forces there. It's going to be a short war.
I am currently running 1.02d (patch under matrix release). I read about new beta patch, but saw there are still bugs, so decided to wait for next official patch to update, which I hope happens soon.
It's been 1 year since war started, and I still don't have any new generals. I did discover a bug though. So before the war, I colonized Oklahoma and Arizona so the cherokee and apachee Indians are under my command, with general Stand Watie. I put them all in Oklahoma before the war. When War started, a found the CSA has a new general Stand Watie, but I still have same general under me too. So now there are 2 generals Stand Watie on the map! I didn't know 19th century cloning technology was so advanced!
Anyway, in the first year of war I was not impressed with AI tactical abilities. It sent the Army of Northern VA to the west, trying to take Southern Illonois, but failed and was cut off. Now it is trapped and rotting in Ohio. Meanwhile, in the absence of his big army, I was able to march down VA and surround Richmond. So 1 year into the war, the CSA capital is besieged, and its best army is doomed to be destroyed in Ohio, and I also took most of Texas after he vacated his forces there. It's going to be a short war.
I am currently running 1.02d (patch under matrix release). I read about new beta patch, but saw there are still bugs, so decided to wait for next official patch to update, which I hope happens soon.
Give me some days and I will create a custom patch for you. ETA on the weekend.
Indeed, some of these cloning incidents are possible as the spawning of a General is random, as long as he is in the time frame of his era. So perhaps Watie was a historical Confederate allied Indian General that may have continued after the civil war with the USA. For the moment, let's just say he is a cousin of the same name.
Usually, the PON Civil War in the Grand Campaign is small for the reasons I explained before (point 4). If you want a real challenge, try the dedicated Civil War scenario of PON, or grab a copy of the specific games: AACW or CWII.
Indeed, some of these cloning incidents are possible as the spawning of a General is random, as long as he is in the time frame of his era. So perhaps Watie was a historical Confederate allied Indian General that may have continued after the civil war with the USA. For the moment, let's just say he is a cousin of the same name.
Usually, the PON Civil War in the Grand Campaign is small for the reasons I explained before (point 4). If you want a real challenge, try the dedicated Civil War scenario of PON, or grab a copy of the specific games: AACW or CWII.Care to unify Germany as Austria? Recreate the Holy Roman Empire of the 20th Century:
Großdeutschland Mod
Are you tough enough to impersonate the Shogun and defy the Westerners? Prove it:
Shogun Defiance Mod (completed AAR)
Großdeutschland Mod
Are you tough enough to impersonate the Shogun and defy the Westerners? Prove it:
Shogun Defiance Mod (completed AAR)
OK, put this to your Plugin1850 (notebook) file in the Events folder of your installation.
The turn you run it it will activate. You will not notice anything. The turn after, 5 new Generals (two 3-star and three 2-star) should spawn at Washington. Good luck!
PS. After your CW is over, let me know here cause you will need to revert your objectives (F10) to the normal overseas ones. This was another missing script we noticed in our PBEM.
Code: Select all
SelectFaction = $CMN
SelectRegion = $Anglia
StartEvent = Update of American Civil War Leader Quotas for the USA|1|1|NULL|NULL|$Anglia|NULL
Actions
SelectFaction = $USA
ChangeLeadersPool = 3;2
ChangeLeadersPool = 2;3
EndEventThe turn you run it it will activate. You will not notice anything. The turn after, 5 new Generals (two 3-star and three 2-star) should spawn at Washington. Good luck!
PS. After your CW is over, let me know here cause you will need to revert your objectives (F10) to the normal overseas ones. This was another missing script we noticed in our PBEM.
Care to unify Germany as Austria? Recreate the Holy Roman Empire of the 20th Century:
Großdeutschland Mod
Are you tough enough to impersonate the Shogun and defy the Westerners? Prove it:
Shogun Defiance Mod (completed AAR)
Großdeutschland Mod
Are you tough enough to impersonate the Shogun and defy the Westerners? Prove it:
Shogun Defiance Mod (completed AAR)
Thanks Kensai!
I did get 5 new generals, but they were all 2star (but 2 had events saying they were promoted to MG, still only 2star though). I still have Winfield Scott kicking around though, so is it possible that he is taking a 3star slot? (I think I have a 3star in the west too, but I can't remember his name... I just remember that he activates about 1 turn in 5! so that might be another slot taken?)
I did get 5 new generals, but they were all 2star (but 2 had events saying they were promoted to MG, still only 2star though). I still have Winfield Scott kicking around though, so is it possible that he is taking a 3star slot? (I think I have a 3star in the west too, but I can't remember his name... I just remember that he activates about 1 turn in 5! so that might be another slot taken?)
Indeed, these are your maximum quotas, you might have already reached them. Otherwise, it might be that no other 3-star General (max number already appeared) is available. In this case, you need to promote the 2-star through battle. Remember, you can have as many 3-star Generals as you wish through promotion.
Personally, I tend to promote only the best, even if I can more, as keeping 2-star Generals is important for march-to-the-sound-of-guns. Moreover, I tend to leave only one 3-star General per Theater of operations. Use the filter to see which are which. There are also sea theaters for Admirals, try to read which they are through the Areas file in the GameData folder, as they don't appear through the in-game filter.
Personally, I tend to promote only the best, even if I can more, as keeping 2-star Generals is important for march-to-the-sound-of-guns. Moreover, I tend to leave only one 3-star General per Theater of operations. Use the filter to see which are which. There are also sea theaters for Admirals, try to read which they are through the Areas file in the GameData folder, as they don't appear through the in-game filter.
Care to unify Germany as Austria? Recreate the Holy Roman Empire of the 20th Century:
Großdeutschland Mod
Are you tough enough to impersonate the Shogun and defy the Westerners? Prove it:
Shogun Defiance Mod (completed AAR)
Großdeutschland Mod
Are you tough enough to impersonate the Shogun and defy the Westerners? Prove it:
Shogun Defiance Mod (completed AAR)
Kensai wrote:
PS. After your CW is over, let me know here cause you will need to revert your objectives (F10) to the normal overseas ones. This was another missing script we noticed in our PBEM.
so the civil war is over.
It wasn't as bad as I thought, but some interesting things happened, like Robert E. Lee became a Union general (even before the generals patch). Also, even though war ended, there are still slaves in the south. when will they disappear? Do I have to wait to historical date of Emancipation proclamation or 13th amendment for slaves to disappear? (now it's Aug 1862)
Thanks again, Kensai
edit: never mind about slaves, they were gone by event 1 turn later.
The first time I fought the ACW (many patches ago) I found it much harder than now. Took less than 18 months to finish it (and that was with a month or 2 sitting around Richmond with the garrison bug). Its supposed to be difficult and destructive. Not sure what can be done to make it more like that struggle that defined the US though. Maybe if I hadn't built any land forces beforehand and had done more to build up the South in the 50's...
On a slightly more on topic thing... the event that you wrote Kensai, if I added a second version but replaced "SelectFaction = $USA" with "SelectFaction = $CSA", would that add generals to the CSA too? that might make the war a little more tricky (though the AI moving all its forces into the mid-west and leaving the East weakly defended didn't help them!)
Anyway, thanks again Kensai
On a slightly more on topic thing... the event that you wrote Kensai, if I added a second version but replaced "SelectFaction = $USA" with "SelectFaction = $CSA", would that add generals to the CSA too? that might make the war a little more tricky (though the AI moving all its forces into the mid-west and leaving the East weakly defended didn't help them!)
Anyway, thanks again Kensai
No problem, guys, we are all here to help each other.
Indeed, you can adapt the script to anything you want. You might not see the changes you imagine if the CSA, for example, has already reached the max number of AI Generals/Admirals it can get for that time era (leaders have dateIn and dateOut constrains). Remember to change the title of the event as well, as it will be already referenced and won't run again with the same title.
In case your Civil War is over take a look at the F10 screen. Unfortunately the event that reverts the objectives to the pre-CW (overseas) ones is non-existent and the US player sticks to the internal ones, meant for the Civil War. Please run this to revert them to the previous ones, more or less. Do not worry, there are events to add more objectives further down the line.
You could even play with the regions and the score they add to make custom scenarios of your own interest. But please be careful, the command "Objectives" will delete all previous ones and reset them with the new ones you type.
Indeed, you can adapt the script to anything you want. You might not see the changes you imagine if the CSA, for example, has already reached the max number of AI Generals/Admirals it can get for that time era (leaders have dateIn and dateOut constrains). Remember to change the title of the event as well, as it will be already referenced and won't run again with the same title.
In case your Civil War is over take a look at the F10 screen. Unfortunately the event that reverts the objectives to the pre-CW (overseas) ones is non-existent and the US player sticks to the internal ones, meant for the Civil War. Please run this to revert them to the previous ones, more or less. Do not worry, there are events to add more objectives further down the line.
Code: Select all
SelectFaction = $CMN
SelectRegion = $Washington
StartEvent = Objectives for USA (1865 - corrected)|1|1|NULL|NULL|$Washington|NULL
Actions
SelectFaction = $USA
Objectives = $Washington;20;$New York;20;$Chicago;15;$Dallas;5;$San Francisco;10;$Denver;5;$Saint Louis;5;$New Orleans;5;$Mineapolis;3;$El Paso;3;$Shanghai;8;$Puerto Rico;8;$Manila;10;$La Havana;8
EndEventYou could even play with the regions and the score they add to make custom scenarios of your own interest. But please be careful, the command "Objectives" will delete all previous ones and reset them with the new ones you type.
Care to unify Germany as Austria? Recreate the Holy Roman Empire of the 20th Century:
Großdeutschland Mod
Are you tough enough to impersonate the Shogun and defy the Westerners? Prove it:
Shogun Defiance Mod (completed AAR)
Großdeutschland Mod
Are you tough enough to impersonate the Shogun and defy the Westerners? Prove it:
Shogun Defiance Mod (completed AAR)
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 13 guests