tc237
Colonel
Posts: 316
Joined: Sat Mar 04, 2006 10:37 pm
Location: Allegheny Arsenal

Tue May 08, 2007 2:04 pm

McNaughton,

Can you post an example in the "How to mod our games?" section of the forum? (when you have time, of course)

This would help anyone that wants to experiment with different game values and setups.
It will help to build a knowledge base for would-be modders.
It would take some pressure off of Ageod from having to "customize" the game to every players preference.

User avatar
Pocus
Posts: 25669
Joined: Wed Oct 19, 2005 7:37 am
Location: Lyon (France)

Wed May 09, 2007 7:23 pm

right, at the element level flavor naming is still not coded, this is high on the list though.

Theorically, no 2 units of the same name can appears ,except by events.
Image


Hofstadter's Law: "It always takes longer than you expect, even when you take into account Hofstadter's law."

User avatar
McNaughton
Posts: 2766
Joined: Wed Mar 21, 2007 8:47 pm
Location: Toronto, Canada

Wed May 09, 2007 9:10 pm

Regarding the process, I am filtering through the unit files first, clearing up any anomolies (i.e., in one cavalry file, found that "MO" was written as "Mo", and some "s" left out of tennessee along with other slight errors and inconsistencies). Next, once a big patch comes out I will work on the events and scenarios (since corrections there will require work to be done over again!). I have all of the cavalry done (added "Cav." to most units, unless they already had it, or Dragoon, or Hussars, in their name), started militia and volunteers (daunting task), as well as filtered through some regular infantry (Maryland, North and South Carolina, Tennessee and a few others I can't think off hand).

I find Artillery somewhat confusing, maybe add (in brackets) what type of gun the unit is at the end, for example, (6lb).

How to is fairly easy, just using notepad has given me no bad side effects.

User avatar
marecone
Posts: 1530
Joined: Tue Jan 02, 2007 11:44 am
Location: Zagreb, Croatia

Thu May 10, 2007 8:36 am

Great news. We had a discussion about arty few months ago. Their names are a bit strange but it seemed as a best idea back then.
Thank you once again for clearing the data base.

Godspeed

P.S. Did you try playing with those cleaned data?
Forrest said something about killing a Yankee for each of his horses that they shot. In the last days of the war, Forrest had killed 30 of the enemy and had 30 horses shot from under him. In a brief but savage conflict, a Yankee soldier "saw glory for himself" with an opportunity to kill the famous Confederate General... Forrest killed the fellow. Making 31 Yankees personally killed, and 30 horses lost...

He remarked, "I ended the war a horse ahead."

User avatar
McNaughton
Posts: 2766
Joined: Wed Mar 21, 2007 8:47 pm
Location: Toronto, Canada

Thu May 10, 2007 11:53 am

Yeah, the cleared up data appears fine. I really didn't notice too many problems before modding, since the mistypes are very minimal and small.

turska
Conscript
Posts: 19
Joined: Mon May 14, 2007 7:00 am

Tue May 15, 2007 2:43 pm

I think i have 3 brigades called as 2nd Tennesee in my game.

User avatar
Stonewall
Posts: 267
Joined: Sat Mar 17, 2007 4:33 pm
Location: Florida, USA

Tue May 15, 2007 8:18 pm

Awesome work here.

User avatar
McNaughton
Posts: 2766
Joined: Wed Mar 21, 2007 8:47 pm
Location: Toronto, Canada

Tue May 15, 2007 10:07 pm

turska wrote:I think i have 3 brigades called as 2nd Tennesee in my game.


Were they from the same 'class' of brigade? Each different brigade class gets a unit names file, and if there are some differences (spaces that we cannot see), then you will be getting multiple units. I did notice that in one scenario there are two 1st Tennessee Cavalry Regiments on map at the start.

turska
Conscript
Posts: 19
Joined: Mon May 14, 2007 7:00 am

Wed May 16, 2007 7:31 am

McNaughton wrote:Were they from the same 'class' of brigade? Each different brigade class gets a unit names file, and if there are some differences (spaces that we cannot see), then you will be getting multiple units. I did notice that in one scenario there are two 1st Tennessee Cavalry Regiments on map at the start.


One is those bigger infantry bridages with 5(?) regimetns and two are formed from 3 regiments. (2 x inf and a cav i think)

User avatar
Pocus
Posts: 25669
Joined: Wed Oct 19, 2005 7:37 am
Location: Lyon (France)

Wed May 16, 2007 9:20 am

McNaughton, are you still willing to work on the unit names in the excel file? We can add officially your clean up perhaps?
Image


Hofstadter's Law: "It always takes longer than you expect, even when you take into account Hofstadter's law."

User avatar
McNaughton
Posts: 2766
Joined: Wed Mar 21, 2007 8:47 pm
Location: Toronto, Canada

Wed May 16, 2007 10:35 am

Pocus, sorry, yes I have been working on the unit names file since I recieved it. It is a lot of work, and will take me a while longer to complete. I am in the midst of sifting through the artillery units. (I have been through regular volunteers and cavalry, plus a few others)

*I have renamed "Medical" to "Field Hospital", is this ok?
**I have also given balloon units historic names (i.e., Balloon 'Union', and 'Silk Dress Balloon', which were historic names)
***I have given all brigade units the tag 'bde.' at the end to differentiate them from single element regiment units.

1st Maryland Bde.|2nd Maryland Bde.|3rd Maryland Bde.|4th Maryland Bde.|5th Maryland Bde. Bde|6th Maryland Bde.|7th Maryland Bde.|8th Maryland Bde.|9th Maryland Bde.

****I have added the tag 'Cav.' to all cavalry units.

1st Maryland 'Union Cav.'|1st Maryland Potomac Cav.|2nd Maryland Cav.|3rd Maryland 'Bradford Dragoons'|Maryland 'Purnell Legion' Cav.

*****I have chaned all ship squadron units from using the tag 'sq.' to the elongated 'squadron' (it appears to fit well)

Transport Squadron #1|Transport Squadron #2|Transport Squadron #3|Transport Squadron #4|Transport Squadron #5|Transport Squadron #6|Transport Squadron #7|Transport Squadron #8|Transport Squadron #9|Transport Squadron #10|Transport Squadron #11|Transport Squadron #12|Transport Squadron #13|Transport Squadron #14|Transport Squadron #15|Transport Squadron #16|Transport Squadron #17|Transport Squadron #18|Transport Squadron #19|Transport Squadron #20|Transport Squadron #21|Transport Squadron #22|Transport Squadron #23|Transport Squadron #24|Transport Squadron #25|Transport Squadron #26|Transport Squadron #27|Transport Squadron #28|Transport Squadron #29|Transport Squadron #30

******I have stopped modding scenarios and events, since AGEOD mentioned that these are still being modded.
*******I am adding 'Mil.' tag to all militia units (unless they have other tags, like State Troops).

7th New York Mil.|8th New York 'Wash'ton Greys'|11th New York 'Wash'ton Rifles'|12th New York 'Italian Guard'|13th New York 'National Grays'|15th New York Mil.|16th New York Mil.|17th New York Mil.|18th New York Mil.|19th New York 'Parmenter Rifles'|21st New York 'Ellsworth Greys'|22nd New York 'Union Greys'|23rd New York|24th New York|25th New York 'Albany Rgt'|28th New York 'Rifles'|37th New York|47th New York|50th New York|52nd New York|54th New York|55th New York|56th New York|58th New York Mil.|65th New York Mil.|67th New York Mil.|68th New York Mil.|69th New York 'National Cadets'|71st New York 'American Rifles'|74th New York Mil.|77th New York Mil.|84th New York Mil.|94th New York Mil.|98th New York Mil.|99th New York Mil.|102nd New York 'Lindsay Blues'

...and a few other things...

*I am also going to sift through every name to see if some are too long, and abbreviate them a bit more.

Turska, I really don't know why it is doing this, as the other state brigades seem to be working fine. I will look through the Tennessee names, but I have modded them so any discrepency may be eliminated.

User avatar
Pocus
Posts: 25669
Joined: Wed Oct 19, 2005 7:37 am
Location: Lyon (France)

Wed May 16, 2007 1:14 pm

sound good for me.

typo there:
Maryland Bde.|5th Maryland Bde. Bde|6th Maryland Bde.|7th

One thing which would be of interest to clear things up would be to remove from the list the areas of recruitment that can't possibly be used by a given type. For example all artilleries types share the same list, which list:

a) all possible states
b) the MAP tag (= the name can be used everywhere)

the more logical thing would be to remove from (a) the states not used for a particular artillery. You follow me there?

Also don't hesitate to flesh the list with the MAP tag, if there is not enough names. Also some militias lists should be inflated I think.

Thanks for this volunteer work :)
Image


Hofstadter's Law: "It always takes longer than you expect, even when you take into account Hofstadter's law."

User avatar
McNaughton
Posts: 2766
Joined: Wed Mar 21, 2007 8:47 pm
Location: Toronto, Canada

Wed May 16, 2007 9:50 pm

Pocus wrote:sound good for me.

typo there:
Maryland Bde.|5th Maryland Bde. Bde|6th Maryland Bde.|7th

One thing which would be of interest to clear things up would be to remove from the list the areas of recruitment that can't possibly be used by a given type. For example all artilleries types share the same list, which list:

a) all possible states
b) the MAP tag (= the name can be used everywhere)

the more logical thing would be to remove from (a) the states not used for a particular artillery. You follow me there?

Also don't hesitate to flesh the list with the MAP tag, if there is not enough names. Also some militias lists should be inflated I think.

Thanks for this volunteer work :)


Good catch on the Maryland Bde. Bde! Thanks!

I have already split off the Cavalry into state specfic lists (i.e., only Alabama units in the $AL section), and am doing so for the Artillery as well (as per your request in the e-mail).

I will add the MAP tag to all artillery and cavalry, however, the names are very short for the CSA (USA tends to apply regular U.S. Army names, CSA seems to be vacant. Should I just continue with extra state names (i.e., 100th Alabama Cav.), or create a series of C.S. Cav. units?

There wasn't any Wisconsin artillery in the original list, so I found some batteries online and added them.

For militias, I will just continue with the state and numbering system for additional Militia units. Depending on the state, I will add another 10 or 20 militia unit names.

User avatar
McNaughton
Posts: 2766
Joined: Wed Mar 21, 2007 8:47 pm
Location: Toronto, Canada

Confederate Brigades

Thu May 17, 2007 2:00 am

I am wondering about Confederate brigades. Would it be a good idea to add some named brigades for the first few units in the Unit files? For example, Georgia would have...

Archer's Bde.
Barton's Bde.
Benning's Bde.
Colquitt's Bde.
Lawton's Bde.
etc...

Then continue on with numbered Brigades...

1st Georgia Bde.
2nd Georgia Bde.
etc...

Any thoughts?

User avatar
Stonewall
Posts: 267
Joined: Sat Mar 17, 2007 4:33 pm
Location: Florida, USA

Thu May 17, 2007 3:22 am

McNaughton wrote:I am wondering about Confederate brigades. Would it be a good idea to add some named brigades for the first few units in the Unit files? For example, Georgia would have...

Archer's Bde.
Barton's Bde.
Benning's Bde.
Colquitt's Bde.
Lawton's Bde.
etc...

Then continue on with numbered Brigades...

1st Georgia Bde.
2nd Georgia Bde.
etc...

Any thoughts?


I think thats an excellent idea.

User avatar
Pocus
Posts: 25669
Joined: Wed Oct 19, 2005 7:37 am
Location: Lyon (France)

Thu May 17, 2007 7:15 am

good one. Actually the flavor names found were at the regiment level (the same list exists in the models.xls file) but we did not ask to find names of brigades.

In the end we will need one list for the units and one list for the models.

Ok for the flavor names at the brigade level.
Image


Hofstadter's Law: "It always takes longer than you expect, even when you take into account Hofstadter's law."

User avatar
rickd79
Colonel
Posts: 347
Joined: Wed Jan 24, 2007 12:40 pm
Location: Connecticut

Thu May 17, 2007 1:18 pm

McNaughton wrote:I am wondering about Confederate brigades. Would it be a good idea to add some named brigades for the first few units in the Unit files? For example, Georgia would have...

Archer's Bde.
Barton's Bde.
Benning's Bde.
Colquitt's Bde.
Lawton's Bde.
etc...

Then continue on with numbered Brigades...

1st Georgia Bde.
2nd Georgia Bde.
etc...

Any thoughts?


Interesting idea....maybe we need a separate post to talk about this issue exclusively.....
We might need to come to some sort of consensus on certain brigade names.
For instance, would you call one of the brigades Toombs' Brigade or Benning's Brigade? (they were the same unit...Benning took over later) Alternatively, we could just have both names in the database.

User avatar
McNaughton
Posts: 2766
Joined: Wed Mar 21, 2007 8:47 pm
Location: Toronto, Canada

Thu May 17, 2007 9:22 pm

rickd79 wrote:Interesting idea....maybe we need a separate post to talk about this issue exclusively.....
We might need to come to some sort of consensus on certain brigade names.
For instance, would you call one of the brigades Toombs' Brigade or Benning's Brigade? (they were the same unit...Benning took over later) Alternatively, we could just have both names in the database.


I was thinking about this, and was going to base the choice either on which was the first unit name, or which name was tagged to the unit the longest, or which was well known (IMO, "Toombs' Brigade" was famous at Antietam). The Brigade name didn't always match the commander, as eventually either promoted or KIA, someone else would get in charge, yet, the brigade would retain the previous commander's name.

Good idea about the separate thread, to get a list created to cover the major brigades for the states (checking to see if they are gained via event, or are at the start of the 1861 scenarios).

*Having both names leads to the 'problem' that technically they are the same unit, just named after someone else. I am leaning toward basing it on the following priority.

#1. The First Name (i.e., Toombs' gets more priority over Benning's because Toombs' was first)
#2. Fame (if the unit was more famous as Benning's Brigade than Toombs', even though Toombs' came first)
#3. Time (if the unit was named Toombs' for 1 year, but Benning's for 4 years, then this must be a factor, yet not as important as #1 or #2 unless it is very drastic [i.e., 1 month vs 3 years])

User avatar
McNaughton
Posts: 2766
Joined: Wed Mar 21, 2007 8:47 pm
Location: Toronto, Canada

Sun May 27, 2007 11:48 pm

I am still working on this project, it is taking a very long time (due primarily to the new naming system for brigades, after much consideration and looking through documents and OOBs, I think that named union brigades are appropriate as much as Confederate brigades). I have pretty much finished the Union Eastern brigades, and most of the Union SouthWest, but still have to do the 'centre' (Army of the Cumberland, Mississippi and Tennessee). For the Confederates it is much easier, as commanders and formations stayed whole for a greater period of time (although I am amazed at how much the Union forces retained leaderships and unit composition).

User avatar
Carrington
Captain
Posts: 198
Joined: Wed Jan 03, 2007 3:53 am

Tue May 29, 2007 1:42 pm

McNaughton wrote:I was thinking about this, and was going to base the choice either on which was the first unit name, or which name was tagged to the unit the longest, or which was well known (IMO, "Toombs' Brigade" was famous at Antietam). The Brigade name didn't always match the commander, as eventually either promoted or KIA, someone else would get in charge, yet, the brigade would retain the previous commander's name.

Good idea about the separate thread, to get a list created to cover the major brigades for the states (checking to see if they are gained via event, or are at the start of the 1861 scenarios).

*Having both names leads to the 'problem' that technically they are the same unit, just named after someone else. I am leaning toward basing it on the following priority.

#1. The First Name (i.e., Toombs' gets more priority over Benning's because Toombs' was first)
#2. Fame (if the unit was more famous as Benning's Brigade than Toombs', even though Toombs' came first)
#3. Time (if the unit was named Toombs' for 1 year, but Benning's for 4 years, then this must be a factor, yet not as important as #1 or #2 unless it is very drastic [i.e., 1 month vs 3 years])


This is great work, and I'm looking forward to seeing the result. Your priorities sound good, too... The only thing I'd suggest is that the OOBs for the campaign might not need to be as exact, just that an 'appropriate' range of names be generated.

With the campaign's recruitment schedule player controlled, and with a different range of battles, we do create an alternate history with each game -- e.g. in my campaign there could be a Bennings and a Toombs brigade because Toombs' brigade didn't get mauled at an Antietam (that never happened in a particular game) so therefore Bennings got detached to start a new brigade of Georgians(?) (who in real history were absorbed as replacements). (A lot of coulda-woulda-shouldas here, but I don't think this is an unlikely scenario historically).

It's all a bunch of sci-fi thinking -- alternate universes and the like -- but it's interesting in terms of which details need sweating.

By the way, an interesting and affecting article in the Times yesterday about renovations at Greenwood Cemetary in New York City:

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/05/28/nyregion/28civil.html?ref=nyregion

"One volunteer, Barbara Farley, a widow whose husband’s great-grandfather was a Civil War veteran, discovered that one of those buried in Green-Wood, Robert Mitchell, had lived at 5712 14th Avenue in Brooklyn. That was just around the corner from the house where Ms. Farley grew up, at 1364 57th Street. "

Funny...

I read recently that casualties proportional to the Civil War for today's USA would top Six Million.

User avatar
Doomwalker
Brigadier General
Posts: 449
Joined: Mon Apr 30, 2007 4:36 am
Location: Confederate held territory in Afghanistan.

Fri Jun 01, 2007 4:37 pm

What is the latest word on the changes being spoken of in this thread?

User avatar
McNaughton
Posts: 2766
Joined: Wed Mar 21, 2007 8:47 pm
Location: Toronto, Canada

Fri Jun 01, 2007 9:31 pm

Confederates: East and West, all of the research has been done, names sorted, not applied to files.

Union: East, all of the research has been done, names sorted, not applied to files.

Union: West, all of the research has been done, names not sorted or applied to files.

The heavy work has been done, just some sorting of the Union West, and final reorganizing to get them to be applied to the files.

User avatar
McNaughton
Posts: 2766
Joined: Wed Mar 21, 2007 8:47 pm
Location: Toronto, Canada

Sun Jun 03, 2007 2:41 am

Well, I am basically done the research and organization, just some final bits to move around, as well as the cavalry to finish sorting out, and this job is done.

User avatar
Doomwalker
Brigadier General
Posts: 449
Joined: Mon Apr 30, 2007 4:36 am
Location: Confederate held territory in Afghanistan.

Mon Jun 04, 2007 2:49 pm

Well if you would like some help I would be willing to give you some assistance.

User avatar
McNaughton
Posts: 2766
Joined: Wed Mar 21, 2007 8:47 pm
Location: Toronto, Canada

Mon Jun 04, 2007 9:43 pm

Doomwalker wrote:Well if you would like some help I would be willing to give you some assistance.


*MODIFICATIONS*
JULY 5, 2007
LOUISIANA - Louis Hébert given accent to his name, and moved up the 'ladder' slightly
NORTH CAROLINA - F. S. Armistead Commands NC Junior Reserves Brigade (took first commander), John F. Hoke Commands new NC Senior Reserves Brigade (even though these units could be 'volunteer' units, having them as 'regular volunteers' seems to fit).



Well, I am basically done, but if you want to look through the list of names to spot someone I am missing (many states for the Union are lacking in historic leaders, as they really didn't field as many forces to warant that many brigades, Michigan and Wisconsin come to mind). Also, some confederate leaders are missing their first name.

ALABAMA
Wilcox's Bde.|Rodes's Bde.|Law's Bde.|Wood's Bde.|Gladden's Bde.|J. K. Jackson's Bde.|Rust's Bde.|O'Neal's Bde.|Manigault's Bde.|Loomis's Bde|Moore's Bde.|Deas's Bde.|Clayton's Bde.|Gracie's Bde.|Lee's Bde.|Burford's Bde.|Shelley's Bde.|Holtzclaw's Bde.|Pettus' Bde.|T. M. Scott's Bde.|Lowrey's Bde.|Perrin's Bde.|Battle's Bde.|Baker's Bde.|

Cadmus M. Wilcox|Robert Rodes|Evander Law|Sterling A. M. Wood|Adley H. Gladden|John K. Jackson|Albert Rust|Edward A. O'Neal|Arthur M. Manigault|John Q. Loomis|John C. Moore|Zachariah C. Deas|Henry De Lamar Clayton, Sr.|Archibald Gracie, Jr.|Stephen D. Lee|A. Burford|Charles M. Shelley|James Holtzclaw|Edmund W. Pettus|Thomas M. Scott|Mark P. Lowrey|Abner Perrin|Cullen A. Battle|Alpheus Baker|

ARKANSAS
Drake's Bde.|Cabell's Bde.|Colbert's Bde.|McNair's Bde.|McRae's Bde.|Liddell's Bde.|Hindman's Bde.|Fagan's Bde.|Dockery's Bde.|Tappan's Bde.|Beall's Bde.|Hawthorn's Bde.|Polk's Bde.|Govan's Bde.|D. H. Reynolds' Bde.|

(N)Drake|William L. Cabell|W. Bruce Colbert|Evander McNair|Dandridge McRae|St. John R. Liddell|Thomas C. Hindman|James F. Fagan|Thomas P. Dockery|(N)Tappan|W. Beall|Alexander T. Hawthorn|Lucius E. Polk|Daniel C. Govan|Daniel H. Reynolds|

*Drake (served as Brigade commander at Fort Donelson)
*Tappan

FLORIDA
Pryor's Bde.|Perry's Bde.|Brown's Bde.|Trigg's Bde.|Preston's Bde.|Stovall's Bde.|Finley's Bde.|

Roger A. Pryor|Edward A. Perry|John C. Brown|Robert C. Trigg|William Preston|Marcellus A. Stovall|Jesse Finley|

GEORGIA
A. R. Wright's Bde.|Lawton's Bde.|Colquitt's Bde.|J. R. Anderson's Bde.|Semmes' Bde.|Toombs' Bde.|Cobb's Bde.|G. T. Anderson's Bde.|Drayton's Bde.|Thomas' Bde.|Doles' Bde.|Benning's Bde.|Rains' Bde.|Wilson's Bde.|Barton's Bde.|Cumming's Bde.|Wofford's Bde.|Gordon's Bde.|Bryan's Bde.|J. A. Smith's Bde.|Cook's Bde.|Watkins' Bde.|Harrison's Bde.|H. Jackson's Bde.|

Ambrose 'Rans' Wright|Alexander Lawton|Alfred Colquitt|Joseph Reid Anderson|Paul Semmes|Robert Toombs|Howell Cobb|George 'Tige' Anderson|Thomas F. Drayton|Edward L. Thomas|George Doles|Henry L. Benning|James Edward Rains|Claudus C. Wilson|Seth M. Barton|Alfred Cumming|William T. Wofford|John B. Gordon|Goode Bryan|James A. Smith|Philip Cook|Elihu P. Watkins|George P. Harrison|Henry Jackson|

LOUISIANA
Starke's Bde.|Pendleton's Bde.|D. W. Adams' Bde.|Gibson's Bde.|P. Anderson's Bde.|Pond's Bde.|Hébert's Bde.|Shoup's Bde.|Nicholls' Bde.|Stafford's Bde.|Gibson's Bde.|J. Adams' Bde.|Lowry's Bde.|Maxey's Bde.|

William E. Starke|Edmund Pendleton|Daniel W. Adams|Randall L. Gibson|Patton Anderson|Preston Pond, Jr.|Louis Hébert|Francis A. Shoup|Francis T. Nicholls|Leroy A. Stafford|Randall L. Gibson|John Adams|Robert Lowry|S. Maxey|

MISSISSIPPI
Simonton's Bde.|Baldwin's Bde.|Featherston's Bde.|T. M. Jones' Bde.|Statham's Bde.|Chalmers' Bde.|Villepigue's Bde.|Griffith's Bde.|Posey's Bde.|Davis' Bde.|Barksdale's Bde.|Walthall's Bde.|Humphreys' Bde.|Sharp's Bde.|Brantley's Bde.|Sears' Bde.|Harms' Bde.|

(N)Simonton|William E. Baldwin|Winfield S. Featherston|Thomas M. Jones|Winfield S. Statham|James R. Chalmers|John B. Villepigue|Richard Griffith|Carnot Posey|Joseph R. Davis|William Barksdale|Edward C. Walthall|Benjamin G. Humphreys|Jacob H. Sharp|William F. Brantley|Claudius Sears|Nathaniel H. Harms|

*Simonton (Served at Fort Donelson)

MISSOURI
Bowen's Bde.|Little's Bde.|Rains's Bde.|Frost's Bde.|Saunders's Bde.|M. E. Green's Bde.|C. Green's Bde.|Rosser's Bde.|Gates's Bde.|Cockrell's Bde.|

John S. Bowen|Henry Little|James S. Rains|Daniel M. Frost|James P. Saunders|Martin E. Green|Colton Green|Thomas H. Rosser|Elijah Gates|Francis M. Cockrell|

NORTH CAROLINA
Ransom's Bde.|Daniel's Bde.|Walker's Bde.|G. B. Anderson's Bde.|Garland's Bde.|Pender's Bde.|Branch's Bde.|Lane's Bde.|Cooke's Bde.|Grimes' Bde.|Iverson's Bde.|Scales' Bde.|Hoke's Bde.|Pettigrew's Bde.|Clingman's Bde.|Ramseur's Bde.|Daniel's Bde.|Kelly's Bde.|Cox's Bde.|Johnston's Bde.|Kirkland's Bde.|NC Senior Reserves Bde.|NC Junior Reserves Bde.|Hardy's Bde.|Palmer's Bde.|

Robert Ransom Jr.|Junius Daniel|Henry Walker|George B. Anderson|Samuel Garland Jr.|William D. Pender|Lawrence Branch|James H. Lane|John Cooke|Bryan Grimes|Alfred Iverson, Jr.|Alfred M. Scales|Robert Hoke|James J. Pettigrew|Thomas Clingman|Stephen D. Ramseur|Junius Daniel|John H. Kelly|William R. Cox|Robert D. Johnston|William W. Kirkland|John F. Hoke|F. S. Armistead|Washington Hardy|Joseph B. Palmer|

SOUTH CAROLINA
M. Gregg's Bde.|R. H. Anderson's Bde.|Ripley's Bde.|Drayton's Bde.|Kershaw's Bde.|Jenkins' Bde.|Gist's Bde.|Trapier's Bde.|McGowan's Bde.|Hagood's Bde.|Blanchard's Bde.|Kennedy's Bde.|H. R. Field's Bde.|

Maxcy Gregg|Richard H. Anderson|Roswell Ripley|Thomas Drayton|Joseph Kershaw|Micah Jenkins|States Rights Gist|James Trapier|Samuel McGowan|Johnson Hagood|Albert G. Blanchard|John D. Kennedy|Hume R. Field|

TENNESSEE
Archer's Bde.|Brown's Bde.|Heiman's Bde.|Stewart's Bde.|Cleburne's Bde.|B. Johnson's Bde.|Powell's Bde.|Donelson's Bde.|P. Smith's Bde.|Maney's Bde.|A. W. Reynolds' Bde.|Vaughn's Bde.|Bate's Bde.|M. J. Wright's Bde.|Vaughan's Bde.|J. Gregg's Bde.|Strahl's Bde.|Pillow's Bde.|Quarles' Bde.|G. Johnson's Bde.|Carter's Bde.|

James 'Sally' Archer|John C. Brown|A. Heiman|Alexander P. Stewart|Patrick R. Cleburne|Bushrod R. Johnson|Samuel Powell|Daniel S. Donelson|Preston Smith|George Maney|A. W. Reynolds|John C. Vaughn|William B. Bate|Marcus J. Wright|A. J. Vaughan, Jr.|John Gregg|Otho F. Strahl|Gideon J. Pillow|William A. Quarles|George D. Johnson|John C. Carter|

TEXAS
Phifer's Bde.|Roane's Bde.|Waul's Legion|Deshler's Bde.|Ector's Bde.|Polignac's Bde.|Seward's Bde.|Granbury's Bde.|

Charles W. Phifer|John S. Roane|Thomas N. Waul|James Deshler|Matthew D. Ector|Camille de Polignac|H. Seward|Hiram B. Granbury|

VIRGINIA
Mahone's Bde.|Armistead's Bde.|Wise's Bde.|Wharton's Bde.|Campbell’s Bde.|Fulkerson's Bde.|Elzey's Bde.|Trimble's Bde.|Pryor's Bde.|C. Field's Bde.|Kemper's Bde.|J. R. Jones' Bde.|Taliaferro's Bde.|Early's Bde.|Corse's Bde.|Colston's Bde.|(N)Conner's Bde.|French's Bde.|Heth's Bde.|W. Smith's Bde.|W. Scott's Bde.|Steuart's Bde.|Echols' Bde.|T. A. Smith's Bde.|Pegram's Bde.|Lilley's Bde.|

William Mahone|Lewis Armistead|Henry Wise|Gabriel C. Wharton|(N)Campbell|Samuel V. Fulkerson|Arnold Elzey|Isaac Trimble|Roger Pryor|Charles Field|James Kemper|John R. Jones|William Taliaferro|Jubal Anderson Early|Montgomery D. Corse|Raleigh E. Colston|(N)Conner|Samuel French|Henry Heth|William Smith|W. Scott|John Echols|Thomas A. Smith|John Pegram|Robert D. Lilley|

*Campbell (Commanded R. Jones' Brigade before Jones)
*Conner

User avatar
Montbrun
Major
Posts: 249
Joined: Sun May 06, 2007 9:27 pm
Location: Raleigh, NC

Mon Jun 04, 2007 10:13 pm

NORTH CAROLINA:
"*Who Commanded the Junior Reserves Brigade?"


From late 1864 to Bentonville - Col John H. Nethercutt

User avatar
Doomwalker
Brigadier General
Posts: 449
Joined: Mon Apr 30, 2007 4:36 am
Location: Confederate held territory in Afghanistan.

Mon Jun 04, 2007 10:21 pm

Looks like you did some serious research there. I will see if I can scrounge up anything extra, but it looks like you already hit a major chunk of it.

User avatar
Franciscus
Posts: 4571
Joined: Fri Apr 20, 2007 8:31 pm
Location: Portugal

Tue Jun 05, 2007 1:11 am

Amazing work here. Congratulations to you, McNaughton. :hat:

User avatar
McNaughton
Posts: 2766
Joined: Wed Mar 21, 2007 8:47 pm
Location: Toronto, Canada

Tue Jun 05, 2007 1:32 am

I have yet to post the Union, which is significantly more extensive than the Confederates. I still have yet to complete the cavalry brigades (have all the info, just haven't organized them yet).

User avatar
Pocus
Posts: 25669
Joined: Wed Oct 19, 2005 7:37 am
Location: Lyon (France)

Tue Jun 05, 2007 7:30 am

excellent work anyway McNaughton!
Image


Hofstadter's Law: "It always takes longer than you expect, even when you take into account Hofstadter's law."

Return to “Help to improve AACW!”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 8 guests