Page 1 of 1

Two HQs stacked in a single region bug

Posted: Wed Jun 16, 2010 7:02 am
by Drakken
Here is a pic I have taken after Resolution of the CP Military Phase.

The Russian III and V HQ are stacked in Lemberg, which is AFAIK definitely a bug. From what I understand, when the Isolated stack attempted to move out of the pocket I sent in the V Army full force in Interception. However, no combat has happened and it was bounced out of supply to Lemberg while the III Army HQ was still there.

Image

Posted: Wed Jun 16, 2010 8:01 am
by calvinus
The issue is known and there's little chance to fix it without creating nasty side effects.

This is a side effect of adapting a boardgame into a PC game.

There are some cases when two or more stack can be "found" in the same area: retreats and interception, for instance.
In WEGO mode this is not forbidden, in Army-by-Army is not allowed, during movement for sure.

No battle took place probably because one of the two stacks was involved in combat before, so a second battle could not take place.
Again a problem of adapting a boardgame into PC game.

When you play the boardgame, you face such situations and arrange an agreement with your opponent to find a solution on the way. In a PC game this is not possible...

Posted: Wed Jun 16, 2010 5:39 pm
by Drakken
calvinus wrote:
No battle took place probably because one of the two stacks was involved in combat before, so a second battle could not take place.
Again a problem of adapting a boardgame into PC game.


Ah, now I understand.

Indeed, I used Plehve's V Army on the Austrian right-wing to bump off IV Army and close off the pocket around Rawa Ruska. Then, I booked an Interception. By accepting Interception when prompted, then being denied combat, the III and IV Army succeeded in escaping the pocket.

It seems this denial was treated as a defeat, and so my V Army retreated to Lemberg, the closest supply source.

What would have happened, however, if I had refused the Interception? V Army would have remained in position and the pocket would have remained sealed off, so I would have had combat nonetheless and blocked III and IV Army from passing through? :bonk: