Just wondering, I live in Missouri and I ordered this game about 2 weeks ago. . . just wondering if anyone else who has bought it can tell me about how long it took to receive the game?
Thanks
-
Primasprit
- Posts: 1614
- Joined: Mon Jun 19, 2006 7:44 pm
- Location: Germany
In order to keep the shipping cost affordable, we use the French and US postal services...so 2 to 3 weeks is rather standard. It usually takes 2-3 days for the parcel to leave France, then US Mail takes over and the time really depends on where you live in America, larger cities getting parcel first usually 
PhilThib wrote:In order to keep the shipping cost affordable, we use the French and US postal services...so 2 to 3 weeks is rather standard. It usually takes 2-3 days for the parcel to leave France, then US Mail takes over and the time really depends on where you live in America, larger cities getting parcel first usually
Great, thanks for the information!
coldsteel ,the battleground games are really good,but have you tried the Mad Minute games Take Command Second Manassas.There's some great mods available that add Antietam,Chickamauga and Fredricksburg to the original game.Just as Ageods game is by far the best stratigic game on the civil war,I would say Take Command Second Manassas is the best tactical game out there.
Take Command does for the Civil War what Combat Mission does for WW II: unrivaled excellence in tactical level combat.
There is a lot of potential scope in the Tiller games, but you need to find a human opponent to play the Civil War campaigns: the AI is more or less incompetant.
As an old-time board wargamer I thought I could get around this problem by playing myself head-to-head, but that kills the fog of war and makes strategic surprises close to impossible, even if you're very forgetful.
Still, the enormous size of some of his maps make them very seductive, but I wonder if the games do a very good job of representing operational issues. When you get away from the tactical level (which Take Command does a far better and exciting job of simulating) you start to get the impression with Tiller that all they did was to make the maps really big -- they didn't do much to the game engine to reflect logistics or attrition. I suspect that the dynamic campaigns with the branching decision trees come a bit closer to simulating the larger scale issues, but they do this by sweeping a lot of details under the rug.
I still remember my dissapointment when I started playing the Seven Days campaign as the Confederates and noticed that the Union troops kept losing their artillery train because they would advance down a road through a forest with no scouts and limbered guns at the head of their columns. Then I played the Atlanta Campaign as the Union and noticed that the AI didn't have a clue about what to do with its artillery on defense.
That kind of thing doesn't happen with the Take Command series.
There is a lot of potential scope in the Tiller games, but you need to find a human opponent to play the Civil War campaigns: the AI is more or less incompetant.
As an old-time board wargamer I thought I could get around this problem by playing myself head-to-head, but that kills the fog of war and makes strategic surprises close to impossible, even if you're very forgetful.
Still, the enormous size of some of his maps make them very seductive, but I wonder if the games do a very good job of representing operational issues. When you get away from the tactical level (which Take Command does a far better and exciting job of simulating) you start to get the impression with Tiller that all they did was to make the maps really big -- they didn't do much to the game engine to reflect logistics or attrition. I suspect that the dynamic campaigns with the branching decision trees come a bit closer to simulating the larger scale issues, but they do this by sweeping a lot of details under the rug.
I still remember my dissapointment when I started playing the Seven Days campaign as the Confederates and noticed that the Union troops kept losing their artillery train because they would advance down a road through a forest with no scouts and limbered guns at the head of their columns. Then I played the Atlanta Campaign as the Union and noticed that the AI didn't have a clue about what to do with its artillery on defense.
That kind of thing doesn't happen with the Take Command series.
Ian Coote wrote:coldsteel ,the battleground games are really good,but have you tried the Mad Minute games Take Command Second Manassas.There's some great mods available that add Antietam,Chickamauga and Fredricksburg to the original game.Just as Ageods game is by far the best stratigic game on the civil war,I would say Take Command Second Manassas is the best tactical game out there.
Cool, thanks a lot. . . I have not heard of the "take command" game. . . but then again. . I don't get quite the time on the computer that I used to be used too. . . you know, wife and kid now
I might have to check that out!
Coldsteel, if you can download 800 MB and provide me with your order references, I can give you the digital version of the game while you wait for the box: [email="support@ageod.com"]support@ageod.com[/email]
Hofstadter's Law: "It always takes longer than you expect, even when you take into account Hofstadter's law."
-
Chamberlain
- Captain
- Posts: 182
- Joined: Wed Apr 18, 2007 7:46 pm
- Location: New York
Coldsteel wrote:Cool, thanks a lot. . . I have not heard of the "take command" game. . . but then again. . I don't get quite the time on the computer that I used to be used too. . . you know, wife and kid now
I might have to check that out!
Coldsteel, here is the link to Take Command 2nd Manassas :
http://www.madminutegames.com/
Check it out, and yes, you can have both games (I do) on your computer.
Chamberlain
There's a small but reliable company in Florida that specializes in naval simulations that can not only get you a copy of 2nd Manassas, but can probably find you a relatively inexpensive (and probably slightly used) copy of 1rst Bull Run, which is hard to find because it is hopelessly out of print. I'm reluctant to mention their name because I don't remember what the policy is on that kind of thing on this site.
I'm embarassed to say I haven't played either game with mods. 2nd Manassas is much more sophisticated to look at than 1rst Bull Run, but 1rst Bull Run is a lot of fun to play and is great for learning the system. After you've played 2nd Manassas, though, I would imagine that it would be pretty hard to go back.
By the way, does anyone happen to know if there was any snow on the ground during the battle of Fredericksburg?
By the way, does anyone happen to know if there was any snow on the ground during the battle of Fredericksburg?
Philippe wrote:I'm embarassed to say I haven't played either game with mods. 2nd Manassas is much more sophisticated to look at than 1rst Bull Run, but 1rst Bull Run is a lot of fun to play and is great for learning the system. After you've played 2nd Manassas, though, I would imagine that it would be pretty hard to go back.
By the way, does anyone happen to know if there was any snow on the ground during the battle of Fredericksburg?
There wasn´t snow on Gods & Generals movie depictment of the battle...
But i'm not sure if this is a good historical source...
The film was mighty boring so one could hope that at least they should had done their historical research right...
Are you trying the new TC2M Fredericksburg mod??
Cheers!
-
Jojo le Gouffy
- Captain
- Posts: 151
- Joined: Thu May 03, 2007 4:36 pm
I didn't want to install it unless I was sure it was accurate. Ground conditions have a big impact on tactical actions, and it's not merely a question of visuals.
I've seen a contemporary print of troops milling around one of the buildings near Marye's Heights within a few weeks of the battle (pretty sure it was the same year) and the ground clearly had snow on it. I haven't read any contemporary accounts of the battle, but that (or a discussion of ground conditions by a reputable historian like Shelby Foote) is what you would need to establish something like that. Having said that, the snow may have fallen after the battle (or I was in a hurry when I was looking at the print and got the year of the print and the battle mixed up). There used to be an old wives tale that battles provoked rainfall...
Movies tend to have visuals that the producers think will please their audience, and they test (and subsequently rewrite and reshoot) their product with focus groups to make sure they have the formula right. They have to do this because there's too much money at stake, and they can't afford the commerical risk (or so they think). Truth is the first casualty of war, and historical accuracy is usually the first casualty of commercial film-making.
I've seen a contemporary print of troops milling around one of the buildings near Marye's Heights within a few weeks of the battle (pretty sure it was the same year) and the ground clearly had snow on it. I haven't read any contemporary accounts of the battle, but that (or a discussion of ground conditions by a reputable historian like Shelby Foote) is what you would need to establish something like that. Having said that, the snow may have fallen after the battle (or I was in a hurry when I was looking at the print and got the year of the print and the battle mixed up). There used to be an old wives tale that battles provoked rainfall...
Movies tend to have visuals that the producers think will please their audience, and they test (and subsequently rewrite and reshoot) their product with focus groups to make sure they have the formula right. They have to do this because there's too much money at stake, and they can't afford the commerical risk (or so they think). Truth is the first casualty of war, and historical accuracy is usually the first casualty of commercial film-making.
They have a section on mods on their forum.Antietam Chickamauga and Fredricksburg have seperate downloads of Maps for the battles with scenarios,it takes the game to a whole new level,highley recommended.The only problem I had, was that for me anyway there not the easiest mods to install,but if you have a problem there's a great bunch of guys on their forum that will help you out.As far as snow on the Fredricksburg Battlefield Photographs taken shortly after the battle do appear to show patches of snow on the ground.
On rechecking my copy of O'Reilly's book The Fredericksburg Campaign he says at the start of chapter six.Fog blanketed Fredericksburg again on December 13,promising another day of unseasonable warmth.The weather observer in Georgetown recorded the temperrature as thirty four degrees at 7:am.By 2:00pm,the mercury rose to nearly sixty degrees.Frost on the battlefield quickly gave way to mud.
-
Jojo le Gouffy
- Captain
- Posts: 151
- Joined: Thu May 03, 2007 4:36 pm
a) no mention of snow in the text pp31 to 87 ( the two days battle)
b) no snow on photographs taken during this time
c) no snow on drawings and battlefield maps.
only freezed ground and freezed grass
page 6 the autor notices (en français souligne) the wide swings of temperature in Virginia
Et j'espère que mon anglais est correct
b) no snow on photographs taken during this time
c) no snow on drawings and battlefield maps.
only freezed ground and freezed grass
page 6 the autor notices (en français souligne) the wide swings of temperature in Virginia
Et j'espère que mon anglais est correct
-
Jojo le Gouffy
- Captain
- Posts: 151
- Joined: Thu May 03, 2007 4:36 pm
Super en français c'est plus simple.
Et j'aime le gag de deux francophones qui parlent anglais pour mieux se comprendre.
Donc pas de neige à Fredericksburg le jour de la bataille.
Cela ne veut pas dire qu'il n'y en a pas eu durant la campagne entière et la phase d'approche mais de la à précider quels jours, c'est difficile
Et j'aime le gag de deux francophones qui parlent anglais pour mieux se comprendre.
Donc pas de neige à Fredericksburg le jour de la bataille.
Cela ne veut pas dire qu'il n'y en a pas eu durant la campagne entière et la phase d'approche mais de la à précider quels jours, c'est difficile
-
Jojo le Gouffy
- Captain
- Posts: 151
- Joined: Thu May 03, 2007 4:36 pm
Return to “AGEod's American Civil War”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 33 guests