Tue May 21, 2013 6:03 am
Hold at all cost order, when introduced, changed this game completely. It became almost impossible to won on a attack, if not substantially stronger. I have had situations when I forgot to put the unit on hold at all cost and they fled before the battle (such was the disparity). If it was on, they would surely have won the engagement.
It would be unhistorical, if victory would be determined according to casualties (as in AJE for example), and not according to who held the field at the end since the victory was always claimed by the one who held the field at the end.
With Grant commanding your offensive stack, attacking 1 division commanded by 3-1-1 general with two-three of his own in clear terrain, you might not force him out if he is holding at all cost, but you will surely devastate defending division, completely destroying it after first day of battle. Maybe if battle lasts for more than 1 day, your initial orders could be "interpreted-changed" by your commanding officer (in role playing terms he has done all humanly possible to hold his positions, but enough is enough), resulting in retreats before 100% casualties (no division stood their ground when facing 100% casualties if they had an escape route).
Personally, I use hold at all cost a lot, because I do not want my units to leave theirs entrenchments without a fight, or without calling for MTSG. I once had one division defending an amphibious invasion. Athena landed with an Union army in Kentucky, and my division fled before the battle. Out of curiosity, I rerun the turn, put my div to hold at all cost, and they devastated the Union army inflicting 40.000 casualties.
If it would be possible, I would like retreat roles before the battle to be calculated according to expected battle outcome (including possible MSTG), not according to disparity in strength points of the two forces. Than, maybe, hold at all cost would not be so necessary.
And to allow hold at all cost units to retreat on the second day of battle. Even Lee retreated on the second day of Sharpsburg (Antietam). And you could argue in game terms he was on hold at all costs posture.