czert2 wrote:3. event for makno anarchists to switch sides to whites after reds betray them as they did in reality,
but well, no idea about condition for it
- whites pushed from ukraine? few great battles between whites and anarchists? certain date?
czert2 wrote:6. allow whites to sign peace (not alliance) with greens (universaly or region specific?) since sometimes greens allied with whites against reds (for stratetical/combat reason, not idealogical), but still they attacked whites too (but well, i dont know about situation in which they allied with reds against whites).
Andatiep explanation:The Lev wrote: for hardcore players one could open up the possibility of playing as Makhno in the Grand campaign/Polish soviet war scenario
. What I already asked (thread is openened) is a scenario (DLC?) about Ukraine:Andatiep wrote:(...) Politically, the Ukrainian Anarchists faction could not attack the Reds first. After all, they wanted a political fight to convert the masses supporting the Reds, not to force them like the Bolsheviks. Each time they fought against the Red Army, they know they fought against brothers manipulated by a minority of Bolsheviks so they always tried to avoid conventional fights, which is hard to simulate in a wargame !
In any territories they did developed and reinforced, it is in territories where the Bolsheviks terror was not present. Makhno had no other choice than hoping for peace with the Bolsheviks till he get stronger enough so that they give up with their wish to control all Ukraine including the "Free Territory" of the Blacks. Of courses there where nothing to hope about that.
So if Makhno can't decide to fight the Reds when he want and can't ally with the Whites, why making him a different playable faction than the Reds one ? Because it could be more fun to play the game with 4 Human players, 2 per side...? OK, but the Black player will really have few things to manage during all the game.... not like the Eastern White player who have similar amount of things to manage than the Western White player.
Together with the huge works needed to MOD it, that's why we chose an other way to give an other destiny to the Blacks in the game : If the Red player chose the political Option to avoid a Bolshevik dictatorship, he couldn't later chose to crush the Ukrainian anarchists any more and the Black troops will enlarge the "Free territory" where they are used in Ukraine and finish the game possibly controlling all Ukraine as "free territory" but allied with the Reds.
The Lev wrote:Keep up the good work ERISS, know that we appreciate it
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest