Hi!
We’re playing a PBEM game of the long campaign of the RUS Gold game. I’m the red player and it seems that there’s something wrong with the “Northwest peace” decision, as I have the required cities (Olonets, Petrograd and Pskov) but there’s no peace at all. Maybe there’s some missing text or the decision doesn’t work?
And some thoughts about the campaign. We’ve played PBEM two times that long campaign and the two the reds will lose the game because the loss of national morale every single turn due to not having Minsk, Kiev, Ekaterinoslav, etc. (and Tallinn, because that “Nortwest peace” issue). Isn’t that loss too harsh? Are those cities that important?
.
Dortmund wrote:Hi!
We’re playing a PBEM game of the long campaign of the RUS Gold game. I’m the red player and it seems that there’s something wrong with the “Northwest peace” decision, as I have the required cities (Olonets, Petrograd and Pskov) but there’s no peace at all. Maybe there’s some missing text or the decision doesn’t work?
I will need the saved game files of the turn before you tried to have a look about that...
Dortmund wrote:And some thoughts about the campaign. We’ve played PBEM two times that long campaign and the two the reds will lose the game because the loss of national morale every single turn due to not having Minsk, Kiev, Ekaterinoslav, etc. (and Tallinn, because that “Nortwest peace” issue). Isn’t that loss too harsh? Are those cities that important?
Yes, this cities are important. If the Reds don't hold it it means the Poles are winning. But you should have then a Polish Victory event which freeze all Belorussia and Ukraine and then let the Red NM in peace. The Red could then only win with VPs.
Don't you got the Polish victory event which stop the NM malus for the Reds ?
I will also need a set of saved game files to have a look about that...
REVOLUTION UNDER SIEGE GOLD
No, there's no polish event... at least not yet!
I attach here the game files of our current turn. You'll see that I have selected the northwest peace event and I have the three required cities, but when you run the turn there's no peace at all. And that during at least 15-20 turns (15-20 less national morale).
I attach here the game files of our current turn. You'll see that I have selected the northwest peace event and I have the three required cities, but when you run the turn there's no peace at all. And that during at least 15-20 turns (15-20 less national morale).
- Attachments
-
- DOWARPI.rar
- (333.03 KiB) Downloaded 202 times
Dortmund wrote:No, there's no polish event... at least not yet!
I attach here the game files of our current turn. You'll see that I have selected the northwest peace event and I have the three required cities, but when you run the turn there's no peace at all. And that during at least 15-20 turns (15-20 less national morale).
I need ALL the files of a saved game, not only the Reds' turn & orders.
REVOLUTION UNDER SIEGE GOLD
@Dortmund :
If i look at the saved game, the Polish victory conditions are not ready since the Reds still control Kiev and Kharkov... Take it and you will have your Polish Victory...
And if i look at the VPs scores, the Whites will then probably win the game at the end of the year 1921...
Polish victory conditions are listed in the National Policies Option's tooltip of Miracle on the Vistula, or in the ENGLISH-Game Events Chronology.pdf file in the .../Docs/ repository.
PS : Hello Picaron
Nice you are playing it !REVOLUTION UNDER SIEGE GOLD
About the Peace in the Nort-West Option, Reds can't activate it because, as said in the Option tooltip, they need to control ALL towns of the Olonets, Petrograd and Pskov sectors. They currently don't own the towns of Seghezha, Medvezhya Gora, Petrozavodsk, Vytegra, and Polotsk...
Clean the borders from Russian Whites and you may have peace with Finland and Baltic states...
Clean the borders from Russian Whites and you may have peace with Finland and Baltic states...
REVOLUTION UNDER SIEGE GOLD
Dortmund wrote:, the text is there. I didn't read it well. It says "all the cities" and I thought (I don't know why) that I needed only the capital cities of that regions.
andatiep wrote: as said in the Option tooltip, they need to control ALL towns of the Olonets, Petrograd and Pskov sectors.
A 'town' is generally larger than a 'village' and smaller than a 'city'.
So the word is important, 'town' word must be used, 'city' can be misleading (what might have happen here, Dortmud you may have understand well what was written, but it was maybe not so well written). I think 'town' can include 'city' in the meaning, not the reverse.
'Village' too could be misleading, even some rares are written on the map (GullyayePollie was rather a village than a town, I think). I think 'village' does not include 'town' or 'city' in the meaning.
So, who's right?
Have the tooltip to be made better?Return to “Revolution Under Siege”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 6 guests