Edward "Allegheny" Johnson - I understand there are time constraints with the artwork, but wouldn't you need him for the 1863 Gettysburg Confederate Order of Battle? (He was a division commander in the II Corps...his division had the Stonewall Brigade. By the way, I'm just guessing that you will hav...

I see an entry for a George K Warren in the Union Army. Is this a reference to Gouverneur K. Warren? USA George K. Warren ldr_USA_Warren2 NULL NULL NULL NULL 4 4 2 33 General 1 NULL 3 3 4 USA George K. Warren ldr_USA_Warren NULL NULL NULL NULL 4 4 1 26 General 1 NULL 3 3 4 Govenerneur Warren was chi...

USA Ambrose Burnside ldr_USA_Burnside3 NULL NULL NULL NULL 6 5 3 16 General 1 NULL 2 2 3 USA Ambrose Burnside ldr_USA_Burnside2 NULL NULL NULL NULL 6 10 2 5 General 1 NULL 2 2 3 First off, it looks like Burside does not have an entry as a Division commander (historically, he rose to Corps command pr...

"Strong Morale" might be another good trait for "Stonewall" Jackson: "Strong Morale: This element is composed of highly motivated, battle-hardened individuals. The inspiration they provide give a +5 Maximum Cohesion bonus to all others elements of the unit they are in." This seem appropriate. (After...

CSA Lafayette McLaws ldr_CSA_McLaws NULL NULL NULL NULL 1 1 1 19 General 1 NULL 3 1 1 This may be overly picky...but it seems like Lafayette McLaws is getting underrated a bit as a division commander. Solid, yet unspectacular would be the description that seems appropriate. I would suggest 3/2/3.......

Agreed....Howard did perform better once he was moved out west.
3/3/2 seems like a nice compromise.

You might also consider throwing in the "Surpriser" trait, in homage to his Flank Assault at the Battle of Chancellorsville. One might also make the argument that this "Surprise" was more the result of Federal commanders ignoring reports of a large body of troops moving around their flank, than Jack...

USA Oliver Howard ldr_USA_Howard2 NULL NULL NULL NULL 4 5 2 7 General 1 NULL 4 3 3 Given his XI Corps' performance on the defensive at the Battles of Chancellorsvile and Gettysburg, I think you might consider dropping Oliver Howard's strategic and defensive ratings. (Some of the blame must fall to h...

Darius Couch: USA Darius N. Couch ldr_USA_Couch NULL NULL NULL NULL 7 10 1 22 General 1 NULL 2 2 2 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darius_N._Couch Couch commanded the Federal II Corps at Fredricksburg and Chancellorsville, so you may want to add a Corps Commander entry for him. He didn't get along well...

Looking at the ratings a little more closely, I think A.P. Hill deserves a bit of a bump as a division commander. Take a look at his performance: Seven Days Battles : A bit of a mixed performance, but that was on par with most of Lee's commanders during this period (Jackson was uncharacteristically ...

274 USA John Sedgewick ldr_USA_Sedgewick2 NULL NULL NULL NULL 4 4 2 19 General 1 NULL 4 3 4 299 USA John Sedgewick ldr_USA_Sedgewick NULL NULL NULL NULL 4 4 1 10 General 1 NULL 4 3 4 First of all, it looks like you have John Sedgwick's last name mispelled in the spreadsheet (sorry, I know...minor de...

141 CSA John B. Hood ldr_CSA_Hood3 NULL NULL NULL NULL 13 15 3 8 General 1 NULL 6 4 1 162 CSA John B. Hood ldr_CSA_Hood2 NULL NULL NULL NULL 8 5 2 19 General 1 NULL 6 4 1 198 CSA John B. Hood ldr_CSA_Hood NULL NULL NULL NULL 3 3 1 25 General 1 NULL 6 4 1 John B. Hood: Hood is very well regarded as a...

Hi, I'm new to the forum, but I'm intrigued by how well this game seems to be coming together. 157 CSA Ambrose P. Hill ldr_CSA_APHill2 NULL NULL NULL NULL 6 5 2 14 General 1 NULL 5 1 1 193 CSA Ambrose P. Hill ldr_CSA_APHill NULL NULL NULL NULL 1 1 1 20 General 1 NULL 5 1 1 A.P. Hill: This seems like...