- Cyberstratege (9/10): Simply the best wargame on the operationnal scale
- Nxgenerationgamers.com (85/100): a fun and fairly accurate romp through early America
- Gamershall.de (7.8/10): A respectable game worth its price
- Avid Gamer (7/10): Definitely worth shelling out
- NewGenGamers (69%): "you really have no excuse not to have it in your collection"
- PC Gamer UK (77%): "A strategic delight"
- PC4War gives WIA 8/10 rating
- gamezine.co.uk - 7/10
- Armchairgeneral Review
- 2404.org: "...rock-solid, highly polished, and very, very fun." (9.5/10)
- Hooked Gamers: "for any fan of pure strategy board games [...] certainly a must-buy"
- DieHardgameFane: "not for everyone, and it doesn’t try to be" (Score: above average)
- Review on gamerswithjobs
- Meristation: 7/10 (spanish)
- Third place in "Best Strategy Game 2008"-Poll by Gamershall & Strategycon Interactive
- TCancer Review & Primer for WiA 1.05